Skip to content
MyTwins
Crib Mattresses

Do I need two crib mattresses for twins?

Yes, two. And buy new for both. Used mattresses are linked to elevated SIDS risk.

Verdict

Buy two

Buy new
Buy 2Buy newSafety note

Why

Safe-sleep evidence on used mattresses is the strongest single argument against buying used. Buy new for both.

Safety note

Mattress must be firm and fit the crib with no gaps.

When to buy
When you buy the cribs.
Budget pick
Graco Premium Foam Mattress (~$70 each).
Premium pick
Newton Baby breathable, washable mattress (~$300 each).

Twin-tested gear

What we'd look at

Newton Baby Crib MattressNewton Baby · Crib Mattresses$300 each

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Breathable, washable mattress popular with safe-sleep-conscious twin parents.Buy 2Buy new
Graco Premium Foam Crib MattressGraco · Crib Mattresses$70 each

Graco Premium Foam Crib Mattress

Budget GREENGUARD-Gold foam mattress. Cheapest twin-pair pick that's not sketchy.Buy 2Buy new

Long-form

Related guides